Montréal Sector18:25:14
Mars StationSol 410,894 08:50:22
The Belt7.60.43
Titan AnnexBeat 369.07
Corporate InstitutionalBank of Time0001
A lone arbitrator at a curved bench beneath a window of stars

Legal › 3027 › Ellsworth v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time

Arbitration ruling

Ellsworth v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time

Citation
[3027] CIBT Arb 7
Claimant
Uma Ellsworth
Arbitrator
Teodor Lindqvist

Concerning a joint account whose holders had agreed a division of the savings but never of the drawings.

A lone arbitrator at a curved bench beneath a window of stars
Plate I A lone arbitrator at a curved bench beneath a window of stars. From the Bank's archive.

The facts

Two holders of a joint account at Ring Road each kept a card and a key. They drew on it in turn for most of a year, and then one stopped. The other holder went on drawing, and the Bank posted her withdrawals without comparing them against either card. The dispute concerns a joint account whose holders had agreed a division of the savings but never of the drawings.

When the partnership ended, the joint account at Ring Road lay against a claim that was later withdrawn until it was divided by a method the Bank chose rather than one the holders had agreed: half to each, whatever each had paid in.

The arguments

The claimant does not dispute that the account was joint. The claimant disputes that the Bank had any power to let one holder move the whole of it after the partnership ended in 3026.

The Bank submits that a joint account may be drawn on by either holder until both have signed it closed. A letter asking for the account to be divided is not that signature, however fairly it is put. The Bank sent the division form in 3026, and the form was never returned. Until then the account stood as the holders opened it, and the copy of the letter was kept behind the counter, under the day's cash tray.

Findings

The joint form made each holder a party to the other's withdrawals. A withdrawal taken after the partnership ended was taken without the consent the form requires, and a Bank holding a freeze request could have stopped it.

A joint account is one account in two names. I find that after 3026 neither holder could move the whole of it without the other's written consent, and that the withdrawals made without it must be reversed.

Ruling

The notice of separation takes effect from the day both holders signed it, and the account is divided on that day. The Bank will enter the division against both names and send each holder her half in writing.

Teodor Lindqvist, Arbitrator

Doc. ref. CIBT-3027-663F-3