Montréal Sector18:25:16
Mars StationSol 410,894 08:50:24
The Belt7.60.49
Titan AnnexBeat 369.07
Corporate InstitutionalBank of Time0001
Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre

Legal › 3027 › Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Yeboah (on appeal)

Arbitration ruling · Appeal Panel

Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Yeboah (on appeal)

Citation
[3027] CIBT Arb 6 (Appeal)
Appellant
Ines Yeboah
Panel
Zeno Fothergill (presiding), Wim Kestrel, Caio Okonkwo
On appeal from
Award of Soren Vantongeren, January 3026

Appeal by the depositor against the arbitrator's award.

Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre
Plate I Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre. From the Bank's archive.

Background

A survey crew at Ganymede left its balance at the Spindle Branch when it was sent out in 3026. The Bank moved the balance to the dormant register during the crew's absence, and the crew did not return for 23 years. The survivors say a balance held for people the Bank could have found should have run at the active rate. The Bank has asked that the difference between the dormant and the active rates on a balance left at a mining station be decided on the terms alone.

Soren Vantongeren, the arbitrator below, followed Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Grisolm [3024] CIBT Arb 8, and the appeal turns largely on whether that ruling governs this one.

Grounds of appeal

  1. That the arbitrator charged the depositor the difference between two rates, one printed for 2906 and one for 3026, without deciding which of them was still in force when the money was lodged.
  2. That the arbitrator divided a dormant balance between two heirs, although the register had last been corrected in 3026 and nobody had since then confirmed it with the Bank's own records.
  3. That the arbitrator split the difference between the Spindle clock and the Head Office signal, which gives the depositor an hour that neither clock ever showed.

The Bank's answer

The Bank's staff did not hold the pay run. The employer's instruction arrived 23 Standard days after the due date, and the Bank credited the sum within the period its terms allow.

Decision of the Panel

Running a little behind is not, of itself, a fault. The arbitrator was right to take the Spindle clock as the record of the hour, since it is the clock the branch keeps by rule, and no one showed that it had been wound late.

An older rate still governs a deposit lodged while it was published. The deposit was lodged before the rate was withdrawn, and a later sheet cannot be applied backwards. The arbitrator was right to reckon at it.

Order of the Panel

Appeal dismissed. The award below stands.

Signed

Zeno Fothergill · Wim Kestrel · Caio Okonkwo

Doc. ref. CIBT-3027-5637-7