Montréal Sector18:25:11
Mars StationSol 410,894 08:50:19
The Belt7.60.33
Titan AnnexBeat 369.07
Corporate InstitutionalBank of Time0001
Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre

Legal › 3028 › Ostrander v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time

Arbitration ruling

Ostrander v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time

Citation
[3028] CIBT Arb 3
Claimant
Sunniva Ostrander
Arbitrator
Ivo Dunmore

Concerning a sealed case the carrier says it opened once and resealed.

Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre
Plate I Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre. From the Bank's archive.

The facts

The deposit of 302,400 seconds was taken at the Lagrange Four Branch in 3001 and sealed in a bag for Singapore Sector. The bag was opened at a bonded store on the way, checked, and closed again by the store's operator. It reached Singapore Sector with the seal intact and no receipt inside, and the consignee has never been shown the receipt the Bank says was sent. The claim concerns a sealed case the carrier says it opened once and resealed.

A tin box of 302,400 seconds in sealed notes went by post from Lagrange Four to Singapore Sector in 3028, and was found three months later in the wrong sorting house. The box had not been opened, but the seal on it was of the same pattern and not the same seal.

The arguments

The crate was sealed at Singapore Sector and the seal was intact when it reached the branch, so the 302,400 seconds inside it were lost by whoever the Bank chose to carry the crate, not by the claimant.

The stamp at Singapore Sector records the sending of the deposit and not its arrival, and the Bank notes that a stack of statements from a branch that has since closed shows only that a receipt once existed.

Findings

A seal intact on arrival does not prove what the case held when it was sealed. The Bank chose the case, and the Bank must credit the interest the depositor lost while the case sat on the wrong shelf, as Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Kowalczyk-Pemberton [2209] CIBT Arb 9 explains.

A seal intact on arrival shows delivery to the courier, not receipt at the branch. The receiving drawer was not checked for a week, and I find the deposit was in transit until it was entered, as Corporate Institutional Bank of Time v. Blackwood [2282] CIBT Arb 8 held.

Ruling

The sealed case is found to have reached Singapore Sector with its seal broken. The Bank answers for the contents from the moment the seal was broken, and the depositor is to be credited with 302,400 seconds from that date.

Ivo Dunmore, Arbitrator

Doc. ref. CIBT-3028-8EF3-1