Montréal Sector18:25:18
Mars StationSol 410,894 08:50:26
The Belt7.60.55
Titan AnnexBeat 369.07
Corporate InstitutionalBank of Time0001
Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre

Legal › 3028 › Okonkwo v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time

Arbitration ruling

Okonkwo v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time

Citation
[3028] CIBT Arb 20
Claimant
Esme Okonkwo
Arbitrator
Rhea Underhill

Concerning a joint account opened before the Bank printed any form for a separation.

Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre
Plate I Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre. From the Bank's archive.

The facts

The joint account was opened at Grand Concourse in 2998 in the names of two holders who each asked for a copy of the ledger page. Both copies were kept by their holders, and each shows a different balance from 3026. Neither holder has seen the Bank's own page since the separation, and a joint account opened before the Bank printed any form for a separation is what they now dispute.

A joint account at Grand Concourse was closed by letter in 3026. The letter was signed in one holder's name and countersigned in the other's. The second holder says she was in another city that month, and the countersignature appears on a form that was not printed until the following year.

The arguments

A letter from one holder cannot end a joint account, and the claimant says the Bank's notice of separation in 3026 bore one name only. The account remained joint in law until both signatures were on the paper, and the Bank has no second signature to produce.

A separation that has not been lodged with the Bank has no effect on its ledger. The joint terms bind both names until one holder instructs otherwise in the form the Bank requires, and neither holder did.

Findings

Both holders signed the opening form in 2998. The form contains no clause on separation, so the Board looks to the Bank's practice, which is to hold a joint balance until both names agree to its division.

Two letters arriving on the same day cancel each other for the purposes of a joint account. The Bank must act on neither until both holders have signed, as Hightower v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time [1608] CIBT Arb 8 held.

Ruling

The Bank will restore to the joint account the 615,600 seconds withdrawn after the notice of separation. The holders will then divide the balance on a single ledger page, signed by each of them.

Rhea Underhill, Arbitrator

Doc. ref. CIBT-3028-D782-4