Montréal Sector18:25:13
Mars StationSol 410,894 08:50:21
The Belt7.60.40
Titan AnnexBeat 369.07
Corporate InstitutionalBank of Time0001
Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre

Legal › 3027 › Szabo v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time (on appeal)

Arbitration ruling · Appeal Panel

Szabo v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time (on appeal)

Citation
[3027] CIBT Arb 1 (Appeal)
Appellant
Cleo Szabo
Panel
Zola Yardley (presiding), Vito Valderrama, Folke Thistlewood
On appeal from
Award of Nils Oyelaran, September 3027

Appeal brought by Cleo Szabo against the arbitrator's award.

Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre
Plate I Alien delegates in tiers, one bank officer presenting at the centre. From the Bank's archive.

Background

A time-transfer slip was accepted at the Polar Vault Branch in 3026 from a holder who, the Bank now accepts, was asleep in another city that week. The counter record shows the slip was taken and the transfer made. The question is a crate of time sent by sea that left the dock labelled for another world.

The arbitrator below relied on Vantongeren v. Corporate Institutional Bank of Time [3025] CIBT Arb 7, and the appeal turns largely on whether that ruling governs this one.

Grounds of appeal

  1. That the counterfoil the Bank relied on was misfiled under another account at the Polar Vault register, so the arbitrator could not have seen it before deciding the claim was out of time.
  2. That the arbitrator dismissed the heir's claim as late, on the strength of a notice the heir never received.

The Bank's answer

The clock at The Belt was inside the tolerance the Clock Standards Board allows. A difference of 17 minutes is the depositor's reading, not a fault in the Bank's records.

Decision of the Panel

An heir who was not on the register at the date of death is not for that reason shut out. The register was amended before the claim was lodged, and the heir's grant is in order. The arbitrator was right to let the heir be heard. It is dismissed.

The appellant argues the claim was made in time because a letter was sent. Notice sent to a former address is no notice, and the award correctly reached that result.

Order of the Panel

Appeal dismissed. The award below stands in full.

Dissent

The arbitrator took the sum from the Friday count, not the day the money fell due. A count made on the wrong day settles nothing about the day that matters, and the appeal should be allowed.

Folke Thistlewood, dissenting

Signed

Zola Yardley · Vito Valderrama · Folke Thistlewood

Doc. ref. CIBT-3027-8606-6